My friend linearthinker liked my post on Practicing Chaos so much he decided to add some thoughts of his own.
“The difficulty in planning against American doctrine is that Americans neither see fit to follow their doctrine nor even read their manuals.” KGB Document
The KGB demonstrated incredible perception. The day-to-day activities recollected from roughly 30 years in the Federal bureaucracy bear out the truth in their statement. Must have been hell for the Soviets, until they realized what they were up against, and by then it was probably too late. One could paraphrase Churchill endlessly on the frustrations one encountered almost daily while coping with the bureaucracy, citing for instance, the unwilling led by the uninformed in pursuit of the worthless.
I have my own scars to bear witness to the feckless leadership of our Federal bureaucracy, and yet their situation was one to evoke sympathy from even the most callous observer when it was realized they were forced into institutional schizophrenia by the conflicting demands of their purse masters in Congress. I offer into evidence only the environmental vs timber production direction given to the US Forest Service from the 70s through the turn of the century. But even that conflicting direction cannot begin to explain why the bureaucratic machine insisted on reinventing the wheel at every shift in program direction or new daily work challenges.
Go read the whole thing.
Cross Posted at Power and Control
Comments
One response to “More Chaos”
The rulebook for the first edition of the Squad Leader wargame had an introduction in which the author compared the tactical doctrines for Germany, Great Britain, and the U. S.
For the Germans everything was worked out in classroom and field exercises. For the British there was a place for everything, and everything in its place. For the Americans the tactical doctrine amounted to, “Do something, anything. Something’s gotta work.”