Always avoid mixing apples with oranges!

Via Glenn Reynolds, I just learned that the best diet might be to cut out carbohydrates and eat like a cougar.
But not long ago, I also read about about a book postulating that eating lots of carbs is the way to be thin.
Might that work for cougars? Has anyone tried caging them and feeding them an all carb diet?
Sometimes I think there are too many studies and too much information — and most of them are infected by the bias that accompanies Wanting To Be Right. Moreover, each of us has a different metabolism. But telling people to find what works for them is not helpful, as people want answers, and we all want to share what worked for each of us. Carried to extremes, this leads to the anti-salt evangelism we have been witnessing in New York.
I’m having trouble sorting it all out. BTW, I just learned that starvation dramatically raises cholesterol!
But starvation also is said to prolong life, right?
Interestingly, for years they have been making people fast before cholesterol testing. Now the latest research says that’s bunk.
I predict more studies contradicting the previous studies. Etc.


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

5 responses to “Always avoid mixing apples with oranges!”

  1. chuckR Avatar
    chuckR

    I’ve decided to consume nothing but Geritol vitamin pills and bacon.

  2. Veeshir Avatar

    One time I went from 220 to 160 from August to November by not eating any fat.
    Which was difficult for me because I don’t like fish or most fruits and veggies and I drink gallons of milk and loved mayo.
    I ate lots of shrimp/chicken fajitas, lots of “hunan chicken” from Chinese restaurants, spaghetti sauce with very little oil and with chicken breast or chicken or turkey meatballs and lots of carbs, including bread, rice, potatoes (with salsa), and lots of sugar (sherbert and whatnot), no freaking mayo and skim milk, fat free salad dressings (Helmann’s caesar was the best, but I can’t find it anymore).
    I exercised some, mostly calisthenics and sit-ups.
    I had no muscles, but I’ve since built them back up.
    I’m not that thin anymore, but I eat a lot of non-fat stuff still, so I keep it under control.
    My family is from Italy and there aren’t a lot of low-fat Italian dishes.

  3. Bleepless Avatar
    Bleepless

    I gave up on this topic the day I learned that bacon and Scotch are carcinogens.

  4. Brett Avatar
    Brett

    Ted Mooney named the disease a quarter century ago in “Easy Travel to Other Planets”: information sickness.

  5. M. Simon Avatar

    You can’t fool Mother Nature. But Father Nature is a stern disciplinarian.