A sixteenth is a half, in the less is more narrative!

Damn. Just when I was complaining that genealogy shouldn’t matter, along comes someone who says it does.
In this case, Irish-American activist Niall O’Dowd, publisher of IrishCentral.com, and an “adjunct professor at Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism” came up with this startling headline:

Harvard prof Gates is half-Irish, related to cop who arrested him

That headline — along with Mr. O’Dowd’s entire piece — ran as an ABC story.
But when the redoubtable Tom Maguire (I don’t know, but I suspect he might be at least as Irish as Gates) checked out the details, he determined that the headline was highly misleading, in that Gates is at most 1/16th Irish. The Irish ancestor to whom he traced his genealogy was neither his father nor his mother, but a man born in the early part of the 19th century.
(Via Glenn Reynolds, who does not divulge his genealogical background, but who may also be half Irish according to ABC’s journalistic standards.)
By way of disclosure, by the ABC’s genealogical standards I am also half Irish! (And half Norwegian, half Scottish, half German, half Welsh, and half English.)
Not that it matters whether anyone is half Irish. But is it really necessary to act like Ward O’Churchill?
AFTERTHOUGHT: In Mr. O’Dowd’s defense, I think it’s fair to recall the, um, traditional “rule” that all persons who were one-sixteenth black were to be classified as black. So it’s possible that maybe there’s an emerging new kind of half-baked rule (embracing the rules of the oppressor) that if you’re one sixteenth Irish and left wing enough, you too can coattail along with the narrative and call yourself “half-Irish.”
MORE: According to the so-called “one-drop theory,” having a single black ancestor anywhere (meaning less than a sixteenth) would be sufficient to confer the racial legal status of being black, but the one-drop rule was never applied to other races.
One of the great ironies is that even though the rule was abolished, it seems to have a new life.
AND MORE: Regarding the need to be “left wing enough” in order to qualify for identity politics treatment, remember that Clarence Thomas is not black. Similarly, Sarah Palin is not a woman.
Perhaps in some circles being Irish also has to be earned. I mean, the Irish Republican Army is one thing, but Irish Republicans need not apply!


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

5 responses to “A sixteenth is a half, in the less is more narrative!”

  1. M. Simon Avatar

    We are cousins by marriage. My wife is 1/2 Finnish. So we are sort of cousins in law.

  2. M. Simon Avatar

    As far as I am able to tell according to DNA all humans can trace their ancestry to Africa. That makes us all black. But the damn racist in Washington tell me I’m White. Can I demand a DNA test?

  3. Veeshir Avatar
    Veeshir

    How many sixteenths is a “drop”?

  4. lonetown Avatar
    lonetown

    You know what we Scots say – one drop of Irish blood and your still an asshole!
    Just kidding guys.

  5. John Burgess Avatar

    Hmmm… I’m actually half Irish. By these statistics, though, maybe I’m full Irish and thus eligible for an Irish passport. Can I sue AP if the Taoiseach disagrees?