Who's the most full of carp?

On the front page of today's Detroit Free Press, there's a scary article about ferocious killer fish from Asia which are about to invade and destroy Lake Michigan. The situation is said to be as bad as a hurricane:

Immediate action is needed to prevent a flood-prone Illinois river from releasing scores of ferocious Asian carp into Lake Michigan, where they could wreak havoc on the ecosystem of the Great Lakes and surrounding bodies of water.

The urgent threat has Congress debating a bill it could pass as early as this week, authorizing the Army Corps of Engineers to do whatever is necessary to keep the voracious fish out.

The Des Plaines River runs beside the Chicago Sanitary and Ship Canal, which has an electric barrier to stop carp from getting into the Great Lakes. The river is only 100 feet from the canal, and if it floods again as it has the past two years, carp could escape into the canal above the electric barricade.

Scientists just discovered in September that the invasive carp were so far up the river -- and so close to Lake Michigan.

"This is a natural disaster waiting to happen," said Jennifer Nalbone of Great Lakes United in Chicago. "We need to respond to it like we would respond to a hurricane."

Ferocious? Their diet consists of plankton, and they're basically like large goldfish. The problem is that when boats approach, they jump, so they have been known to hit boaters and water skiers. While this jumping habit could result in serious injuries or deaths, that behavior is no more "ferocious" than deer jumping in front of cars, and while the latter is a hazard to motorists I don't think too many people consider deer ferocious animals.

Silver carp can grow to 80 pounds and leap out of the water, endangering boaters and anglers. They feed voraciously on the food other lake species eat, so they could destroy or drastically alter the food chain.

If carp get beyond the electric barrier, officials could use a powerful chemical to kill them. But it also would kill other fish in the area, said Phil Moy, chairman of an advisory panel on the barrier.

Sandbagging along the Des Plaines or poisoning the fish are not long-term solutions, said Marc Gaden, spokesman for the Great Lakes Fishery Commission.

The Chicago canal should be fully or partially closed, he and others said Wednesday.

The canal is an important link to Lake Michigan for barges and recreational boats. The city of Chicago dumps its wastewater into it. But protecting the Great Lakes from carp and other invasive species is paramount, Gaden said.

That sounds like the pure and noble thing to do, doesn't it? And the ferocious invaders from Asia sound every bit like the piscine equivalent of Attila the Hun, poised to destroy underwater civilization.
Experts fear the fish could wipe out sport and commercial fisheries on the Great Lakes.
Except what the experts aren't pointing out is that Lake Michigan is not as ecologically pristine as they'd have you believe. The linchpin of the sport fishing industry happens to be salmon, but there are no native salmon. All the salmon have been introduced (just as the carp once was further south):
Great Lakes recreational fishing generates about $4.5 billion a year, according to 2002 figures from the U.S. General Accounting Office, and the most prized species are exotic salmon and trout.

Ironically, salmon were brought to Lake Michigan in the late 1960s for two reasons: to create an exciting fishing experience for vacationers and to eat the oceangoing alewives that had infested the lake.

At one time, the lake looked after itself, with big fish living off little fish like chubs, lake herring and bottom-dwelling sculpins. The lake also was home to healthy populations of yellow perch, whitefish and burbot, a cousin to the oceangoing cod.

But the system collapsed in the 1950s when overfishing, habitat degradation and the arrival of sea lamprey caused lake trout to disappear. With lake trout gone and no predator to replace it atop the food chain, alewives flourished.

By the mid-1960s, up to 90 percent of the lake's fish "biomass" was alewife. The bacon-strip-sized fish periodically died off by the billions, though, likely because of temperature swings the ocean species was not built to handle.

Beaches up and down the 307-mile-long lake were choked with mounds of rotting flesh crawling with maggots.

"You didn't even walk by the beach down in Milwaukee. It stunk awful," recalled retired DNR fishery chief Lee Kernen. "They needed bulldozers to clean them up. It was that horrible."

Looking for a more exciting alternative to trout fishing, biologists turned to Pacific salmon. Almost instantly, alewife numbers plummeted and salmon fishing exploded in popularity.

Now, the states of Wisconsin, Illinois, Michigan and Indiana engage in a delicate balancing act to keep enough alewives around to feed the salmon, but not so many that they once again dominate the lake.

The states also annually plant nonnative brown and steelhead trout, and the federal government stocks about 2 million native lake trout - a species that evolved in the lake over thousands of years but disappeared in the 1950s.

The result is a paradox, however: Politicians and conservationists tout the value of salmon as a reason to protect and restore the lake.

So, what we have is one non-native species competing against another, while humans pontificate on which non-native species should be allowed to survive in order to be eaten. What would Darwin say?

In Alaska they're worried about invasive Atlantic salmon, and more recently, a new threat has been discovered in the form of captive-bred native species! No, seriously. Apparently, it is evil to allow human-bred captives to breed with their wilder brethren. At least, so say the high priests of ecology:

Fish raised in large ocean pens have genetic traits that make them distinct from their wild counterparts. This has led critics of the fish farming industry to argue that farmed fish that break free - a common occurrence - might breed with native ones, perhaps compromising the health of the entire species and threatening its ability to survive in its natural setting.

Dr. Fleming says the key to avoiding this real ecological danger is to break what is normally considered a biological taboo: deliberately introducing a new species into an ecosystem.

"The real issue is a fascinating one - it's to analyze if it is actually better to be farming Atlantic salmon on the West Coast rather than farming Pacific salmon there," says Dr. Fleming. "That might be considered a heretical idea, in the sense that we would be introducing an exotic species into the Pacific, and all our knowledge of invasive species suggests that we shouldn't do that. But with salmonids, particularly Atlantic salmon, there are indications that that might not be such a bad idea."

Gee, so that means non-native species are actually better for the environment than captive-bred native species.... I sure hope these environmentalists know what they're talking about. One thing I've noticed about environmentalists is that they're very quick to change their minds. Wood burning stoves were once good, but now they're bad. Windmills went from good to bad, then good again. Biodiesel went from good to bad. I can't even keep track of their thoughts on ethanol as fuel. But I'm relieved to hear that (at least for now) non-native fish can be better than captive natives.

There is an old-fashioned, man-made solution to the problem of carp. They have been aquafarmed for countless centuries for food, and they are not only a delicacy in Asia, but they're a main ingredient in Gefilte fish. Plus they're a great source of fish feed as well as Omega-3 oil.

On top of all that, they're fun to catch! Watching the video of this Redneck Carp Fishing Tournament makes me want to throw Coco in the back of my 1964 Ranchero and head for the Mississippi River!


And to wipe out the recalcitrant invaders that the rednecks can't handle, perhaps we could call in the Israelis for help. They've been breeding carp for years to supply the Gefilte fish industry, but lately their carp crop has been devastated by a virus which kills 90% of the fingerlings:

...in the last decade commercial carp breeding has been hit hard by the carp virus, which kills about 90 percent of the fish in the early stage of life. This week about four million carp fingerlings in the fish ponds of the Beit She'an Valley are being immunized against the virus, a step that Agriculture Ministry officials said Wednesday was vital to insuring sufficient supplies of the adult fish ahead of Rosh Hashanah.

Carp virus arrived in Israel in a shipment of koi fish, ornamental varieties of carp. The virus does not affect other species of fish or human beings.

I realize we've got an administration that isn't exactly loved by the Israelis right now. But I think if we asked them nicely, they might at least be willing to share their carp virus with us.

Anyway, I think that if there were a concerted effort between the rednecks and the Israelis, the edible invaders wouldn't stand a chance.

posted by Eric on 10.15.09 at 03:05 PM





TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://classicalvalues.com/cgi-bin/pings.cgi/8910






Comments

Wow, what a bunch of carp.

Dave Price   ·  October 15, 2009 04:06 PM

for all this talk of evolution there seems to be alot of folks who don't want it to happen

newrouter   ·  October 15, 2009 05:25 PM

Hunt and harvest the carp to extinction, and in 20 years we will have the Fish and Wildlife service stocking carp all over.

Gringo   ·  October 15, 2009 11:52 PM

I say, we introduce snake fish to eat them.

Then barracuda to eat the snake fish.

Then the barracuda die in winter.

It's fool-proof.

Veeshir   ·  October 16, 2009 07:27 PM

Yeah, I meant snake-head fish.

It'll still work.

Veeshir   ·  October 16, 2009 07:30 PM

Well I'm Jewish and I hate Gefilte fish. I had enough of it during my childhood to last a lifetime. My grandma's specialty. If you put a lot of horseradish on it it is not too bad.

M. Simon   ·  October 16, 2009 08:21 PM

The Barrier will stop nothing, By protecting the Alewives (salmon food) they left the Lakes wide open for Asian carp. Google Common Carp control using native predators, principle the same. However native fish Perch, walleyes also eat Alewives and compete with salmon thus not allowed. So if we don't lose the salmon we lose the lakes to the asian carp!

Tom Matych   ·  October 18, 2009 04:26 AM

Post a comment

You may use basic HTML for formatting.





Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)


October 2009
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
        1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31

ANCIENT (AND MODERN)
WORLD-WIDE CALENDAR


Search the Site


E-mail



Classics To Go

Classical Values PDA Link



Archives



Recent Entries



Links



Site Credits